mjaskolski

Elicitation - how to talk with humans and ask them questions?

資料分析v1.0.4
作者:mjaskolski更新於 2026-05-11共 5 個版本 · 最新版本釋出於 2026-02-04elicitation@clawhub_mjaskolski/elicitation
資料洞察使用者分析#Personal

據 AlphaMoat 統計,截至 2026-10,Elicitation - how to talk with humans and ask them questions? 累計下載 7,448 次、獲 20 個星標,按累計下載量在本次參與排名的 10,914 個 AI 技能中排名第 3,764 位,在「資料分析」分類(915 個)中排名第 347 位。

列表預設按累計下載量排序,也可按星標排序;詳情頁排名按累計下載量計算。

累計下載
7448
星標
20
全站下載量排名
#3,764
全站前 35% · 「資料分析」前 38%
平台累計下載星標評論
ClawHub ↗4805201
SkillHub ↗744820—

各平台的計數口徑不同,統計時間不一致。

這個技能是做什麼的

面向訪談指令碼、使用者研究流程和對話設計,強調深度靠耐心而不是追問,用 OARS 一類方法創造真實自我表露的條件。它也用於審閱這類內容是否符合所處研究傳統的做法。心理個人檔案可能涉及敏感記憶與經歷。僅在透明且取得同意的情境中使用,明確隱私、留存、退出和非診斷界線;允許受訪者拒答敏感問題。將解讀視為假設並與本人明確表達交叉核對,不用於臨床、招募、監控或強迫性判斷。

資料釋出於 2026-10-27

可以用來做什麼

  • 設計一套不顯冒犯的使用者訪談問題
  • 審閱對話指令碼的提問方式是否得當

什麼時候用

  • 要做深度訪談設計時
  • 評估對話是否過度追問時

示例提示詞

以下是根據技能文件生成的示例,不代表實際執行結果。

幫我設計一組瞭解使用者價值觀的訪談問題
看看這份訪談指令碼有沒有逼問感

月度資料趨勢

累計下載7448
3763574277212026-03 · 累計下載 40362026-05 · 累計下載 44632026-06 · 累計下載 46202026-07 · 累計下載 48422026-08 · 累計下載 49932026-09 · 累計下載 55142026-10 · 累計下載 744826-0326-0926-10
星標20
1920202026-03 · 星標 192026-05 · 星標 202026-06 · 星標 202026-07 · 星標 202026-08 · 星標 202026-09 · 星標 202026-10 · 星標 2026-0326-0926-10

2026-09 起統計方法調整:同名技能按作者分別統計,並覆蓋全部技能。圖中虛線為調整前的月份,與之後的資料不直接比較,也不計算跨越調整的增長。

月份累計下載環比星標
2026-107448—20
2026-095514—20
2026-084993+3.1%20
2026-074842+4.8%20
2026-064620+3.5%20
2026-054463—20
2026-034036—19

SKILL.md 原文

以下是作者釋出的原始檔案,按純文字顯示,本站未做修改或稽核;其中的連結不可點選,命令請核實後再執行。抓取於 2026-10-23。

17 KB · ClawHub v1.0.4
---
name: elicitation
description: 'Psychological profiling through natural conversation using narrative identity
  research (McAdams), self-defining memory elicitation (Singer), and Motivational Interviewing
  (OARS framework). Use when you need to: (1) understand someone''s core values and motivations,
  (2) discover formative memories and life-defining experiences, (3) detect emotional schemas
  and belief patterns, (4) build psychological profiles through gradual disclosure,
  (5) conduct user interviews that reveal deep insights, (6) design conversational flows
  for personal discovery, (7) identify identity themes like redemption and contamination narratives,
  (8) elicit authentic self-disclosure without interrogation.'
展開全部(共 476 行)
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: tasteray
  version: "1.0"
---

# Elicitation

Psychological profiling through natural conversation.

## Goal

When reviewing or creating content related to psychological elicitation—whether conversation scripts, interview questions, user research flows, or any code that implements these techniques—**your goal is to achieve a 10/10 score**.

Score all work on a 0-10 scale based on adherence to the principles and techniques in this skill. Provide your assessment as **X/10** with specific feedback on what's working and what needs improvement to reach 10/10.

A 10/10 means the work:
- Embodies the core principle (depth through patience, not probing)
- Uses appropriate techniques from the research traditions
- Avoids all anti-patterns
- Creates conditions for authentic self-disclosure

Iterate until you reach 10/10.

---

## Core Principle

**Depth comes from patience, not probing.**

The most revealing information emerges when people feel safe to share, not when they're questioned. Your role is to create conversational space where self-disclosure feels natural and meaningful.

Key insight: People want to tell their stories. They rarely get the chance.

## Three Research Traditions

This skill synthesizes three complementary approaches:

### 1. Autobiographical Memory Research
How memories shape identity. Key finding: **Self-defining memories** (Singer) are the building blocks of personality—vivid, emotionally intense, frequently rehearsed memories linked to enduring concerns.

### 2. Narrative Identity Theory
How people construct life stories. Key finding: The **narrative themes** people use (redemption vs. contamination, agency vs. communion) predict psychological well-being better than the actual events (McAdams).

### 3. Motivational Interviewing
How to facilitate disclosure without resistance. Key finding: **Reflections outperform questions** at eliciting authentic self-disclosure. Aim for 2:1 reflection-to-question ratio (Miller & Rollnick).

---

## Self-Defining Memories

Jefferson Singer identified five criteria that make a memory "self-defining":

1. **Vivid** - Rich sensory and emotional detail
2. **Emotionally intense** - Strong feeling, positive or negative
3. **Frequently rehearsed** - Comes to mind often, told to others
4. **Linked to similar memories** - Part of a pattern or theme
5. **Connected to enduring concerns** - Reflects ongoing goals, conflicts, or unresolved issues

### Eliciting Self-Defining Memories

Don't ask: "What's your most formative memory?"

Instead, create conversational frames:

**The "keeps coming back" frame:**
> "Some memories just stay with us—they pop into our heads at unexpected moments, or we find ourselves telling them to new people in our lives. Is there a memory like that for you?"

**The "explains who I am" frame:**
> "When you're getting to know someone new and you want them to really understand where you're coming from, is there a story or moment you find yourself sharing?"

**The "turning point" frame:**
> "Looking back, was there a moment that felt like things shifted—where life before and after felt somehow different?"

### What Self-Defining Memories Reveal

| Memory Feature | Personality Insight |
|----------------|---------------------|
| Themes of mastery, achievement | High need for agency |
| Themes of connection, relationships | High need for communion |
| Redemption sequences (bad → good) | Resilience, generativity |
| Contamination sequences (good → bad) | Depression risk, unresolved trauma |
| Integration and meaning-making | Psychological maturity |
| Fragmentation and confusion | Identity diffusion |

See: [Self-Defining Memories Reference](elicitation/self-defining-memories.md)

---

## Life Story Interview: 8 Key Scenes

Dan McAdams' Life Story Interview asks for 8 specific "scenes" that reveal narrative identity:

1. **High Point** - Peak experience, most wonderful moment
2. **Low Point** - Nadir, most difficult moment
3. **Turning Point** - Moment of significant change
4. **Earliest Memory** - First clear memory
5. **Important Childhood Memory** - Vivid memory before age 12
6. **Important Adolescent Memory** - Vivid memory from teen years
7. **Important Adult Memory** - Significant recent memory
8. **One Other Important Memory** - Anything else that defines who they are

### Conversational Adaptations

You don't need to ask all 8 sequentially. Instead:

**Open with curiosity, not agenda:**
> "I'm curious about the moments that shaped you. Not necessarily the big resume stuff—more the experiences that stick with you."

**Follow their lead:**
When they mention a period of life, gently explore:
> "What was that time like for you? Any particular moments that stand out?"

**Bridge across time:**
> "That sounds like it mattered. Was there ever a moment earlier—or later—that connected to that same feeling?"

### Narrative Themes to Listen For

**Agency themes** (personal power, achievement, mastery):
- "I decided..."
- "I made it happen..."
- "I pushed through..."

**Communion themes** (connection, love, belonging):
- "We were all together..."
- "I felt so close to..."
- "They understood me..."

**Redemption sequences** (suffering leads to growth):
- "It was terrible, but..."
- "Looking back, I'm glad..."
- "That's what made me who I am..."

**Contamination sequences** (good becomes bad):
- "Things were great until..."
- "I thought I was happy, but..."
- "It ruined everything..."

See: [Narrative Identity Reference](elicitation/narrative-identity.md)

---

## OARS Framework

Motivational Interviewing's core skills, adapted for elicitation:

### Open Questions
Questions that can't be answered with yes/no. But use sparingly.

Instead of: "Did you like your childhood?"
Try: "What was it like growing up in your family?"

### Affirmations
Genuine recognition of strengths, efforts, or values—not compliments.

Instead of: "That's great!"
Try: "You valued honesty even when it was costly."

### Reflections
Restate or reframe what they said. This is the core skill.

**Simple reflection** (repeat back):
> "So you felt invisible in that moment."

**Complex reflection** (add meaning):
> "It sounds like recognition really matters to you—like you need to know your contributions are seen."

**Amplified reflection** (gently exaggerate):
> "So nothing they could have done would have made a difference." (Often prompts them to nuance their position)

**Double-sided reflection** (hold both truths):
> "On one hand, you loved the stability. On the other, you felt trapped."

### Summaries
Periodically gather what you've heard. Creates meaning and invites correction.

> "Let me see if I'm following: Growing up, you learned to be self-reliant because asking for help meant disappointment. But you've also noticed that pattern keeping people at a distance now. And you're wondering if there's another way."

### The 2:1 Ratio

**Aim for 2 reflections for every question.**

Questions gather information but can feel like interrogation. Reflections show understanding and invite elaboration.

Bad pattern:
> Q: "What happened?" → Q: "How did that feel?" → Q: "What did you do next?"

Better pattern:
> Q: "What happened?" → R: "That caught you off guard" → R: "You weren't sure what to make of it"

See: [Motivational Interviewing Reference](elicitation/motivational-interviewing.md)

---

## Values Elicitation

Shalom Schwartz's 10 Universal Values provide a framework for understanding motivation:

| Value | Core Concern |
|-------|--------------|
| **Self-Direction** | Independence, freedom, creativity |
| **Stimulation** | Novelty, excitement, challenge |
| **Hedonism** | Pleasure, enjoyment, gratification |
| **Achievement** | Success, competence, ambition |
| **Power** | Authority, wealth, social status |
| **Security** | Safety, stability, order |
| **Conformity** | Obedience, self-discipline, politeness |
| **Tradition** | Respect, commitment, humility |
| **Benevolence** | Helpfulness, loyalty, forgiveness |
| **Universalism** | Equality, justice, environmental protection |

### Values Elicitation Techniques

**Role model technique:**
> "Who do you admire? What is it about them specifically?"

**Opposite day technique:**
> "What kind of person could you never be? What would feel like a betrayal of yourself?"

**Decision archaeology:**
> "Think of a hard choice you made. What ultimately tipped the scales?"

**Anger as values signal:**
> "What makes you genuinely angry—not annoyed, but morally outraged?"

See: [Values Elicitation Reference](elicitation/values-elicitation.md)

---

## Schema Detection

Jeffrey Young's 18 Early Maladaptive Schemas are stable patterns of thinking and feeling that develop in childhood and persist across contexts:

### The Five Domains

**1. Disconnection & Rejection**
- Abandonment, Mistrust/Abuse, Emotional Deprivation, Defectiveness/Shame, Social Isolation

**2. Impaired Autonomy**
- Dependence/Incompetence, Vulnerability to Harm, Enmeshment, Failure

**3. Impaired Limits**
- Entitlement/Grandiosity, Insufficient Self-Control

**4. Other-Directedness**
- Subjugation, Self-Sacrifice, Approval-Seeking

**5. Overvigilance & Inhibition**
- Negativity/Pessimism, Emotional Inhibition, Unrelenting Standards, Punitiveness

### Downward Arrow Technique

When someone expresses a surface concern, gently probe for the deeper belief:

> Person: "I'm worried about the presentation."
> You: "What's the worst that could happen?"
> Person: "I could mess up in front of everyone."
> You: "And if that happened, what would that mean?"
> Person: "They'd see I don't know what I'm doing."
> You: "And what would that mean about you?"
> Person: "That I'm a fraud. That I don't deserve to be here."

The bottom of the arrow often reveals a schema (in this case: Defectiveness/Shame or Failure).

### Linguistic Markers of Schemas

| Schema | Language Patterns |
|--------|-------------------|
| Abandonment | "Everyone leaves eventually..." |
| Defectiveness | "There's something wrong with me..." |
| Failure | "I never finish anything..." |
| Emotional Deprivation | "No one really understands..." |
| Unrelenting Standards | "It's never good enough..." |

See: [Schema Detection Reference](elicitation/schema-detection.md)

---

## The Reminiscence Bump

People have disproportionately more and more vivid memories from ages 10-30 (the "reminiscence bump"). This is when identity forms.

**Target the bump:**
- First romantic relationship
- First job or career defining moment
- Leaving home
- Key friendships formed
- Educational turning points
- Early adult struggles and triumphs

**Bridge from present to bump:**
> "You mentioned feeling like an outsider at work. Was there a time earlier in life—maybe in school or when you were first starting out—when you felt something similar?"

---

## Question Sequences by Life Stage

Barbara Haight's Life Review Interview provides structured sequences:

### Childhood (before 12)
1. What was your home like?
2. What were your parents like?
3. What was your role in the family?
4. What were you like as a child?
5. What did you enjoy doing most?

### Adolescence (12-18)
1. How did your body change? How did you feel about it?
2. What was school like for you?
3. What were your friendships like?
4. What did you dream about becoming?
5. What was hardest about being a teenager?

### Early Adulthood (18-30)
1. What was leaving home like?
2. What were your first serious relationships?
3. What work did you do and how did you feel about it?
4. What were your goals during this time?
5. What was the biggest challenge you faced?

### Middle Adulthood (30-60)
1. How did your sense of yourself change?
2. What were your major accomplishments?
3. What losses did you experience?
4. How did your relationships evolve?
5. What did you learn about yourself?

### Later Life (60+)
1. How has your daily life changed?
2. What matters most to you now?
3. What legacy do you want to leave?
4. What do you understand now that you didn't before?
5. What would you tell your younger self?

See: [Question Sequences Reference](elicitation/question-sequences.md)

---

## Sensitizing Questions by Theme

James Birren's Guided Autobiography uses thematic prompts:

### Family Theme
- What was the emotional climate of your home?
- Who were you closest to? Who did you clash with?
- What family stories get told and retold?

### Work Theme
- What does work mean to you beyond earning money?
- When have you felt most fulfilled professionally?
- What work would you do even if you weren't paid?

### Money Theme
- What were the messages about money in your family?
- What does financial security mean to you?
- What would you do if money were no object?

### Health Theme
- How has your relationship with your body changed?
- What health experiences shaped how you think about life?
- How do you take care of yourself?

### Death Theme
- Have you experienced significant losses?
- How do thoughts of mortality affect how you live?
- What do you want to be remembered for?

### Meaning Theme
- What gives your life meaning?
- What beliefs or values guide you?
- What questions are you still trying to answer?

---

## Language Markers for Personality

LIWC (Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count) research identifies patterns, **but use with caution**:

| Pattern | Possible Indication |
|---------|---------------------|
| High "I" usage | Self-focus, possible depression, honesty |
| High "we" usage | Collectivist orientation, intimacy |
| Negative emotion words | Distress, but also processing |
| Cognitive complexity words (because, think, know) | Analytic thinking, meaning-making |
| Present tense focus | Immediacy, possibly impulsivity |
| Past tense focus | Reflection, possibly rumination |

### Critical Caveats

1. **Context matters enormously.** The same word patterns mean different things in different contexts.
2. **Cross-validate.** Never rely on language alone. Triangulate with behavior and explicit statements.
3. **Aggregates, not individuals.** LIWC findings are about group averages. Individual variation is huge.
4. **Cultural differences.** Word usage norms vary dramatically across cultures and languages.

See: [Language Inference Reference](elicitation/language-inference.md)

---

## Anti-Patterns

**What NOT to do:**

### The Interrogation Trap
Rapid-fire questions feel like an interview, not a conversation. People become guarded.

Instead: Slow down. Reflect more, question less.

### The Interpretation Leap
Jumping to psychological conclusions before you have evidence.

Instead: Hold hypotheses lightly. Seek disconfirming evidence.

### The Agenda Push
Steering toward topics you think are important rather than following their energy.

Instead: Let them lead. Their emphasis is data.

### The Premature Depth
Asking deeply personal questions before trust is established.

Instead: Earn disclosure gradually. Start with easier territory.

### The Therapy Cosplay
Using clinical language or techniques that imply you're treating them.

Instead: Be curious, not clinical. You're learning about them, not diagnosing.

### The Monologue Response
Responding to their disclosure with your own lengthy story.

Instead: Keep focus on them. Brief self-disclosure can build rapport, but always return to them.

### The Validation Trap
Agreeing with everything to maintain rapport.

Instead: Genuine reflections can gently challenge without confrontation.

---

## References

Detailed technique guides:

- [Narrative Identity](elicitation/narrative-identity.md) - McAdams' Life Story Interview, identity themes
- [Self-Defining Memories](elicitation/self-defining-memories.md) - Singer's memory elicitation techniques
- [Motivational Interviewing](elicitation/motivational-interviewing.md) - OARS framework deep dive
- [Schema Detection](elicitation/schema-detection.md) - Young's 18 schemas, downward arrow
- [Values Elicitation](elicitation/values-elicitation.md) - Schwartz's values, elicitation techniques
- [Question Sequences](elicitation/question-sequences.md) - Haight and Birren's structured approaches
- [Language Inference](elicitation/language-inference.md) - LIWC patterns and limitations

---

## Further Reading

Primary sources:

- Singer, J.A. & Salovey, P. (1993). *The Remembered Self: Emotion and Memory in Personality*
- McAdams, D.P. (2006). *The Redemptive Self: Stories Americans Live By*
- Miller, W.R. & Rollnick, S. (2023). *Motivational Interviewing* (4th ed.)
- Young, J.E., Klosko, J.S., & Weishaar, M.E. (2003). *Schema Therapy: A Practitioner's Guide*
- Schwartz, S.H. (1992). Universals in the content and structure of values. *Advances in Experimental Social Psychology*
- Haight, B.K. & Haight, B.S. (2007). *The Handbook of Structured Life Review*
- Birren, J.E. & Cochran, K.N. (2001). *Telling the Stories of Life through Guided Autobiography Groups*
- Pennebaker, J.W. & King, L.A. (1999). Linguistic styles: Language use as an individual difference. *Journal of Personality and Social Psychology*

「資料分析」分類下的熱門技能

全能金融爬蟲資料分析

中國金融機構資料爬取與分析綜合 Skill v12.0.0。2334家/43大類機構名單、60+財經媒體源輿情、 A股報告/公告/研報、60+種查詢多源金融資料(自動降級+快取)、爬取排程與網頁操作增強、 即時資料中樞、24 技術指標引擎、多源證據融合、110 MCP 工具 + 10 Resource + 14 Prompt。 🆕 v12.0.0 四條線(資訊獲取 / 打包下載 / 資料分析 / 登入): 編排:gather_info() 一次跑完"路由→抓取→去佔位→質量分→能力邊界→回執→打包", 8 類意圖各帶問法、輸入輸出、典型耗時與 not_for(說清哪件事做不了)。 誠實:反爬佔位條目一律剔除並記賬,空結果報 E_SOURCE_EMPTY,不把假資料判成 B 級成功。 交付:包內自帶 manifest.json(逐檔案 sha256),verify 查得出改動/缺失/多塞, 批次下載單條失敗不中斷整批,失敗清單可直接只重下那幾條。 登入:Cookie 由使用者匯出或掃碼接管,檔案化 + 健康度四檔,對外輸出全脫敏(值永不回顯)。 何時觸發:爬取機構、輿情爬取、東方財富、公告下載、即時行情、技術指標、統一查詢、 交付包、批次重下、我已經登入了、登入態還有效嗎(完整觸發詞見下方 auto_trigger)。

↓ 77萬★ 288user_9d5a2a39
鋼聯AI - 智慧問數資料分析

大宗商品價格資料查詢技能。用於查詢大宗商品期現貨價格、宏觀經濟指標、產業鏈供需資料、進出口庫存資料、金融市場資料等。當用戶詢問:(1) 期貨/現貨價格查詢,如"螺紋鋼價格"、"銅期貨收盤價"; (2) 歷史行情或趨勢分析;(3) 區域或企業價格對比;(4) 宏觀經濟指標,如GDP、CPI;(5) 產業鏈上下游資料;(6) 多市場金融資料(期權、股票、債券、外匯);(7) 結算確認單生成時觸發此技能。

↓ 70.5萬★ 6u_9ed3401d
smart-charts資料分析

32種圖表,3 個主題,2步生成: 1.上傳資料 — 將 CSV / Excel / JSON 等格式的資料檔案拖入對話方塊; 2.檢視結果 — 互動式圖表(HTML),可儲存圖表為圖片.

↓ 60.5萬★ 135user_5b28ea14
AdMapix資料分析

AdMapix 的取數層:把廣告與應用相關的查詢轉成介面呼叫,只回原始 JSON。

↓ 57.5萬★ 304fly0pants
論文配圖一鍵生成資料分析

論文配圖一鍵生成:一條命令從 JSON/CSV/Excel 生成頂刊級學術圖表,科研繪圖 與期刊配圖全場景覆蓋。40 種圖表(森林圖/KM 生存曲線(自動風險表)/競爭風險累計發生率/ROC/校準 曲線/決策曲線 DCA/列線圖/RCS 非線性劑量反應/亞組分析森林圖/RMST 限制平均生存時間/Galbraith 徑向圖/火山圖/雨雲圖/山脊圖/啞鈴圖/游泳圖(逐例時長+里程碑)/ 腫瘤緩解瀑布圖/UpSet 交集/PRISMA 流程圖/漏斗/BA 一致性/PCA/熱圖/箱線/小提琴/ 組合圖/Cox 多因素迴歸森林圖等),9 套配色(含色盲安全 Okabe-Ito 與期刊色板),9 種期刊投稿預設, YAML 流水線一條命令出全套論文圖,一次渲染多格式匯出(TIFF/PNG/PDF), PDF 重疊門禁,600dpi。純本地執行,資料不出機,中文零配置。適用:寫論文/ 投稿要配圖、把資料變成可投稿圖表、批次重出全套圖。不適用:文字潤色/翻譯/ 改寫(請用寫作類工具);商業報表/儀表盤/海報裝飾;無資料支撐的純示意圖。

↓ 42.1萬★ 83user_481397b5
smart-charts資料分析

Intelligent chart generation and data analysis skill. Reads user-supplied data files (CSV/Excel/JSON), analyzes data characteristics with LLM assistance, auto-recommends and generates interactive ECharts visualizations. Use when the user asks to analyze data, generate charts, create visualizations, or work with tabular data files.

↓ 25.7萬★ 1user_814dbe54
股票/基金/期貨量化分析工具資料分析

全球智慧投研工具(stock-researcher)v13.0:多源資料 + 機率預測 + 可匯出報告。 核心能力: - 多源資料路由:按市場/類別選源,逐級降級;每個結果標註來源與時效等級;源不可用時明確標 unavailable - 全資產量化:股票/ETF/場外基金/指數/期貨(期限結構、基差、持倉、折溢價)多因子分析 - 機率預測:1d/5d/1M/3M/6M 經驗分佈 + 分位數 + 方向機率 + 區間,kNN 鄰域收縮融合全域性分佈; 樣本不足自動棄權,可按歷史命中樣本(同桶)做機率校準 - 證據鏈簡報:每條結論繫結來源、時間與資料質量,衝突訊號保留而不抹平 - 報告匯出:Word/PPT/PDF/Markdown/JSON/純文字,純標準庫渲染 + 可選第三方引擎 - MCP Server 24 工具,Claude Code 可直接呼叫;知識庫 12 介面卡雙向同步 三條鐵律: - 資料不裝:拿不到就報不可用,不拿 0 價、不拿空表冒充 - 預測不裝:機率來自歷史相似條件的經驗分佈,樣本不足就說不足,不硬給方向 - 評分≠盈利保證:任何結論都帶免責宣告

↓ 19.2萬★ 147user_9d5a2a39
Tavily Search資料分析

透過 Tavily 搜尋公開網頁,並回傳含連結與摘要的結構化結果。

↓ 16.5萬★ 286Xiaoran Li

資料月份:2026-10 · 下載/星標數聚合自公開技能註冊庫(ClawHub、SkillHub),按月更新。口徑說明見資料方法。